Information on the change of recommended CTCSS repeater access tone

The following was in the Wireless Institute of Australia news bulletin on the 2nd August 09.

Change of Tone!
Because 123 Hz was prone to interference such as music on the channel, FTAC has decided to revise such & has now set 91.5 Hz as the general use tone for repeaters.
The WIA Band Plan has been Updated to reflect this and other changes, the new Band plans are dated July 24 2009.

The band plan was updated to read-

The following CTCSS tones have been adopted for repeater access:
91.5 Hz: For use with repeaters fitted with CTCSS for interference protection.
141.3 or 146.2 Hz: To activate links to repeaters on other VHF/UHF bands.
85.4 Hz: To activate links to other bands that some operators are not permitted to use.
The previously recommended 123 Hz tone has been withdrawn due to problems with false detecting.

There is much rumour and misunderstanding regarding this change. Some people think the change of tone is mandatory. This is not correct. These CTCSS tones are recommended and are not mandatory. The WIA has no authority to insist any repeaters use any specific subtones. The frequency chosen is entirely up to the individual repeater owners.


Here is Gary VK2ZKT with further information-

As some of you may have heard in the amateur media recently and perhaps discussed on air there has been talk about changing the CTCSS access tone for repeaters to a frequency below 100Hz.
 
Background
Some months ago a meeting was convened in Sydney by a number of repeater operators of metropolitan repeaters and representatives from the WIA technical repeater Committee. The purpose of this meeting was to discuss issues relating to interference and linking issues, especially in large metro areas.  Country areas are not the major problem.
 
A number of Sydney based repeaters suffer various forms of interference including :-
 
In Sydney especially a number of repeater sites are linked to networks that stretch over large distances and are located at high density RF sites.
 
Information Gathered
 
I have contacted the WIA National Office in Melbourne and inquired as to the outcome and possible moves in the area of CTCSS tone access frequencies.
Mr Peter Young VK3MV is the person overseeing this complex issue.
I spoke at length to Diane Ashton in the office and Diane has informed me that no decision has been made as to any if any change to CTCSS frequencies is to be implemented at this stage.
Given the many technical issues revolving around repeater interference a definitive solution is not as simple as it sounds. Interference is a very much site by site issue and the solutions will vary to suit that particular site problem encountered.
Diane indicated that she will follow up with Peter in the coming days and will provide a reply as to the current status of these and other issues.
 
I will let you know as soon as I know.
Regards,
Gary Ryan VK2ZKT

Find below the response I received late today from Mr Peter Young WIA National to my inquiry.
 
Hi Gary
The information you have is rumor, there is NO requirement for repeaters to change tones etc.  Following of forum of repeater builders in Sydney the use of CTCSS would greatly assist in reducing some interference problems being experienced in Sydney and surrounds.  The use of 123 Hz has issues of phantom responses and in heavily RF dense situations, another tone may be preferable.  As the tone 91.5 Hz is in use in Queensland and Victoria it was agreed that this would be used.  Subsequently, John Martin (chairman of NTEC) will now include this tone and a number of others to the list of recommended tones.  In addition further guidance the WIA will recommend the adoption of the commercial standard for use of  CTCSS tones in respect to frequency tolerance, purity (harmonic distortion) and deviation levels for wide and narrow systems (eg 25 kHz and 12.5 kHz).  To a certain extent we are endeavoring to do some strategic planning in this area where RF congestion in respect to amateur repeaters will require management and the use of CTCSS tones is one tool.

There is no requirement for anyone to change repeater tones if there are no problems.

End of story.

Regards
Peter VK3MV